Insights & Events

Extraordinarily Knowledgeable

Sixth Circuit Reinforces Individualized Procedure in MDLs: Practical Lessons for Defense Counsel

publication | November 18, 2026

In a recent article published by Washington Legal Foundation, Hollingsworth LLP Partner Carter F. Thurman examines the Sixth Circuit’s In re OptumRx, Inc. decision reinforcing the importance of individualized procedural protections in multidistrict litigation (MDL). The Sixth Circuit granted mandamus relief and vacated a district court order permitting approximately 800 plaintiffs in the national prescription-opioid MDL to amend their complaints to assert claims against pharmacy benefit managers.

The article explores the decision’s practical implications for defense counsel, including the importance of preserving case-specific objections, developing individualized records concerning plaintiffs’ diligence, insisting on adequate notice of proposed amendments, and documenting prejudice arising from late-stage changes to litigation. Ultimately, the decision underscores that while coordinated procedures can promote efficiency in complex litigation, they cannot displace the procedural requirements governing individual cases.